Thursday, March 3, 2011

Who Holds the Burden of Proof About Bare Feet?

Barefooters are constantly explaining to others why it's okay for us to be unshod -- as if wearing shoes is the natural condition and bare feet are an oddity. Let's be clear: Going barefoot is our natural condition.

Just as having bare hands is the baseline for how we function as human beings, so it should be for feet. We should only wear shoes when truly necessary and when identifiable, legitimate reasons exist. It shouldn't be the obligation of barefooters to prove why we don't need shoes.

Imagine if someone were to say that we should wear gloves on our hands all day long every day. You'd get countless people asking why, claiming it's not necessary and going on without gloves anyway. There are simply not enough legitimate reasons to do such a thing.

It's really the responsibility of those who require shoes to tell us why we and they need them -- and to come up with legitimate reasons. This typically comes in the form of vague excuses of concern over spreading diseases -- which hands do a lot more of, potentially stepping on a sharp object -- which are very few and far between, social appropriateness -- which apparently simply requires any thickness of any material between the soles and the ground, questions of legality -- which, going barefoot isn't illegal, or other not-well-thought-out reasoning.

It's time to start turning the tables on those who discriminate against us. It's time that the burden of proof fall on them to legitimately justify why shoes are so necessary. We need to make them show us the broken glass and not accept their excuses until they do. We need them to take samples of the ground for viral testing to prove that it's unsafe for the public's collective health. We need to make them explain how going barefoot is not acceptable but vulgar t-shirts, patrons with foul odor and people who talk too loudly on their cell phones are. If they claim that going barefoot violates health codes or other laws, they need to show us the proof. If they cannot -- or will not -- do these things, they have no leg to stand on and we must refuse to put on footwear.

Are you a barefooter who finds yourself explaining why your natural state is okay? Do social norms requiring footwear supersede the burden of proof? Are you willing to stand up and turn the tables on discrimination? What do you think would happen if you did? Please leave your comments below.

Photo: Western Rite Critic

6 comments:

  1. I've been saying this all along. If you tell them that they are the ones with the burden of proof and not us, they have nothing left.

    ReplyDelete
  2. People act in the way they are taught. If we want to make a change we have to start when people are young.
    We have to support our own and other children to go barefoot more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A day after reading this post I was in a grocery store that I've been frequenting barefoot for almost a year now. At least 20 visits without shoes. But this time an employee informs me that I can't be in there barefoot.
    .
    Me: Can you show me where it says I can't be barefoot.
    Employee: No, but it's a health code.
    Me: I'm sorry, but that's a myth. There is no such law. [exit SL]
    .
    2 minutes later the "Manager's apprentice" (that's actually what it said on his name badge) with two more large male employees flanking him arrives to tell me I had to leave. Like I'm brandishing a weapon or threatening another customer, or something.
    .
    I've seen a dozen ways to handle this politely, by people far more clueless than him. He didn't ask, he didn't politely inform, he didn't suggest that I wear shoes next time. He cut straight to
    .
    Apprentice: Sir, you have to leave--I can't allow you to be barefoot in here.
    Me: Can you show me where it says I have to wear shoes.
    Apprentice: Sir, I've asked you to leave, and you haven't. Now you're trespassing.
    Me: I just want to see it in writing, because there are a lot of myths about bare feet. Can you show me that your company supports your opinion?
    .
    Note: So far, I have kept it at a conversational polite level the whole time, but now he starts raising his voice.
    .
    Apprentice: Sir you are trespassing. My next step is to call the police.
    Me: Are you seriously saying that you would call the police and say "This is Jeremiah at W***o, come quick, we’ve got a barefoot guy down here?"
    .
    But at this point I knew I needed to back down and leave before I got my dander up and started contributing to the scene he was already making. So I left while I could still pretend to be calm.
    .
    I do believe you're right. We shouldn't have to bear the burden of proof. But I like to go barefoot because it's relaxing and makes me feel connected to the world. Dealing with the adrenaline levels of being confronted by an over-zealous apprentice manager and his intimidating wing-men is the opposite of what I'm after. I may have to hang up my protester hat, and just put on those vile flip-flops I keep under the seat of my truck.

    ReplyDelete
  4. :) This made me happy - last year I was put on two month academic probation at my college for going barefoot. I chose to leave, after all, it was my freedom, and I was paying for that school.
    Keep on writing, I'm loving it!

    ReplyDelete
  5. WINCO has a sign outside their stores that says "Shoes and shirts required by law to be worn inside store". This is a total lie. After they demanded I leave, I tried to get them to identify the law that this refers to, and they said it is "their" law. This from a "manager" fresh out of high school... I haven't been back since (this was in Menifee CA) Stater Bros has never complained about me being there barefoot.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I see on all these walls about shops and other places not accepting us barefooters but what about friends not accepting us??? My friends call me hobo and think I'm crazy and that I need to get a life because I take barefooting seriously one friend said to me (half jokingly half serious)
    "Do you think we should get a doctor or a crazy specialist in or something?"
    Leaving me feeling a little nervous, anyone else get this or is it just me???

    ReplyDelete

Related from LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails